According to Haudricourt, Melvin is being coy.
I'm kind of torn on this one. I'd rather not see any more of our young talent gone. Escobar may be unproven and Gamel hasn't raked(yet), but they are still our future. Mehegeheenee has been great this year, but his durability is definitely a question.
On the other hand we are getting to the point with some of our talent that they may be gone in short order. How long can we keep Fielder happy? It sure seems like Hardy and Hart are involved in every trade rumor. Kendall will most likely be gone next year. As much as people rip on his offense, if we are giving up that much for Halladay you better have a quality veteran catcher and not a rookie calling the shots.
In Melvin we trust?